5 Shocking Recent Developments Inside The Bronx Supreme Court (2025 Judicial Scandal & Key Cases)
The Bronx Supreme Court, a critical pillar of the New York State court system, has undergone significant changes and notable judicial actions in 2025, cementing its status as a central hub for high-stakes litigation in the 12th Judicial District. As of December 19, 2025, the court's operations—spanning both the Civil and Criminal Terms—have been marked by major administrative shifts and disciplinary proceedings, alongside the routine but vital work of adjudicating thousands of civil claims and felony cases. This article provides an in-depth look at the most recent and impactful developments, focusing on judicial conduct, key personnel, and the court's essential functions.
The New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct has been particularly active in 2025, bringing to light two high-profile cases of misconduct involving Bronx Supreme Court judges. These events underscore the court's commitment to judicial integrity and accountability, providing a fresh perspective on the inner workings of one of New York City's busiest courthouses. Understanding these developments is crucial for anyone following New York State law, the judicial system, or local Bronx governance.
Recent Judicial Disciplinary Actions: Censure and Resignation in 2025
The most compelling and recent news surrounding the Bronx Supreme Court in 2025 involves two separate, high-profile judicial misconduct cases that resulted in disciplinary action and resignation. These events highlight the rigorous oversight applied to the judiciary in the 12th Judicial District.
The Censure of Justice Naita A. Semaj (July 2025)
On July 8, 2025, the New York State Commission on Judicial Conduct announced the censure of Supreme Court Justice Naita A. Semaj of Bronx County. The determination stemmed from a finding of repeated poor demeanor on the bench and improper conduct during court proceedings. A judicial censure is a formal public reprimand, signifying a serious breach of judicial ethics. The case serves as a sharp reminder that judicial officers are held to the highest standards of professionalism and temperament, particularly in a high-volume court environment like the Bronx Supreme Court Civil Term.
- Disciplinary Action: Formal Censure
- Date: July 8, 2025
- Reason: Repeated poor demeanor and improper conduct on the bench
The Resignation of Acting Justice Jeffrey M. Zimmerman (March 2025)
Earlier in the year, on March 17, 2025, the Commission on Judicial Conduct announced the resignation of Jeffrey M. Zimmerman, a Judge of the New York City Criminal Court and an Acting Justice of the Supreme Court, Bronx County. Zimmerman's resignation was effective April 3, 2025, and occurred amid a misconduct probe. The investigation centered on allegations that he had interfered with a court proceeding. As part of the stipulation, Zimmerman agreed to never seek or accept judicial office in New York State again, a severe consequence that typically accompanies the most serious findings of misconduct.
- Disciplinary Action: Resignation and agreement not to seek future judicial office
- Date: Announced March 17, 2025 (Effective April 3, 2025)
- Reason: Resignation amid a probe alleging interference with a court proceeding/misconduct
Understanding the Bronx Supreme Court's Dual Structure
The Supreme Court in New York is the trial court of general jurisdiction, and in the Bronx, it is divided into two distinct terms: the Civil Term and the Criminal Term. This dual structure is essential for managing the sheer volume and complexity of cases arising from the borough.
The Civil Term: Handling High-Value Disputes
The Bronx Supreme Court Civil Term is responsible for handling a wide range of civil cases, specifically those where the monetary amount in controversy exceeds $50,000. The court's main location is the Bronx County Courthouse at 851 Grand Concourse. The majority of the Civil Term's docket includes complex and high-stakes litigation, such as:
- Medical Malpractice: Claims against healthcare providers for negligence.
- Labor Law Cases: Often involving construction accidents and workplace injuries.
- Motor Vehicle Accidents: Significant personal injury claims.
- Commercial Disputes: Large-scale business and contract disputes.
Recent Civil Term decisions in 2025, such as *Clarke v Beauzile* (decided February 18, 2025, by Judge Patsy Gouldborne), demonstrate the court's continuous work in resolving civil disputes that impact the lives and businesses of Bronx residents.
The Criminal Term: Jurisdiction Over Felony Cases
The Bronx Supreme Court Criminal Term is the venue for the most serious criminal prosecutions in the borough. Its jurisdiction covers all felony cases—crimes punishable by a sentence of more than one year—as well as some misdemeanor cases. The Criminal Term is located separately at 265 East 161st Street. Key types of cases handled include:
- Homicide and Murder Cases: The most serious charges.
- Weapons and Drug Charges: Major felony narcotics and firearms offenses.
- Assaults and Burglaries: Serious violent and property crimes.
The court has seen several significant criminal decisions in 2025, including *People v Harris* (decided October 1, 2025, Stone, J.), *People v B.S.* (decided April 22, 2025, An, J.), and *People v Nembhard* (decided November 10, 2025, Bowen, J.). These cases are indicative of the court’s rigorous role in the criminal justice system, ensuring due process while managing a high volume of complex criminal litigation.
Key Personnel and Administrative Leadership (2025 Entities)
The effective operation of the Bronx Supreme Court relies on its dedicated administrative staff and a large roster of experienced judges and justices. The leadership structure, as of late 2025, provides essential topical authority and transparency into the court's management.
Administrative Leadership
The court is overseen by two Administrative Judges, one for each term, and their corresponding Chief Clerks, who manage the day-to-day operations:
- Civil Term Administrative Judge: Hon. Joseph Capella
- Civil Term Chief Clerk: Lakisha C. Brown
- Criminal Term Administrative Judge: Hon. Alvin Yearwood
- Criminal Term Chief Clerk: Michelle Foggie
Notable Justices and Judges (A Partial List of Key Entities)
The bench is composed of numerous justices, each presiding over a dedicated Individual Assignment System (I.A.S.) Part. These justices are the core entities of the court, responsible for managing the entirety of their assigned cases from inception to disposition. Key justices currently or recently serving in the Bronx Supreme Court include:
- Justice Paul Alpert
- Justice Adrian Armstrong
- Justice Ben R. Barbato
- Justice Mary Ann Brigantti
- Justice Andrew Cohen (I.A.S. Part 4)
- Justice Mitchell J. Danziger
- Justice Laura G. Douglas
- Justice Patsy Gouldborne
- Justice Stone
- Justice An
- Justice Bowen
- Justice Lester Adler (Criminal Term)
- Justice Beth Beller (Criminal Term)
- Justice Denis J. Boyle (Criminal Term)
- Justice Raymond L. Bruce (Criminal Term)
The presence of these numerous justices and the administrative structure ensures that the Bronx Supreme Court, despite the challenges of a busy urban court, maintains its constitutional mandate to provide a forum for justice. The recent disciplinary actions serve as a testament to the system's checks and balances, ensuring accountability and upholding public confidence in the judicial process.
Detail Author:
- Name : Destiney McClure
- Username : kamille.bahringer
- Email : halle.fritsch@rice.com
- Birthdate : 1993-02-05
- Address : 5126 Powlowski Valley Suite 464 Brownmouth, CA 42234-3722
- Phone : +1 (223) 300-7794
- Company : Kovacek-Schumm
- Job : Medical Sales Representative
- Bio : Tenetur cum excepturi alias tempore facere. Ratione optio omnis quis autem. Et excepturi eius temporibus possimus assumenda et.
Socials
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/cortez_cummings
- username : cortez_cummings
- bio : Blanditiis sit molestiae sunt exercitationem minima. Minus et dolores dolor accusantium sit harum. Odio aspernatur molestiae modi.
- followers : 305
- following : 1449
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@cortez_cummings
- username : cortez_cummings
- bio : Consequatur minima voluptas voluptates est tempore ut porro.
- followers : 1196
- following : 1964
facebook:
- url : https://facebook.com/cortez.cummings
- username : cortez.cummings
- bio : Ipsum aliquid omnis fuga tempora sed id minima.
- followers : 6997
- following : 2136
linkedin:
- url : https://linkedin.com/in/cortez_cummings
- username : cortez_cummings
- bio : Deserunt ut odio vero nemo nisi quia.
- followers : 5889
- following : 586
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/cummings2005
- username : cummings2005
- bio : Adipisci eos dolores eum harum. Eos sapiente et aut necessitatibus et omnis.
- followers : 3589
- following : 49
