The Shocking Divide: Why Emilia Pérez's Rotten Tomatoes Score Has Critics Cheering And Audiences Fuming
The film "Emilia Pérez" has become the most intensely debated movie of the 2025 awards season, creating a chasm on Rotten Tomatoes that few films have ever matched. As of late December 2025, this audacious Spanish-language French musical crime thriller holds a high critical approval rating, yet its audience score sits in a shockingly low range, signaling a profound disagreement between professional reviewers and the general public. This massive disparity—a high 70s percent for critics versus an audience score struggling to break 30%—is the central talking point surrounding a movie that has already swept major awards and is now a frontrunner for the 2025 Academy Awards.
The controversy surrounding the film is as bold as its premise: a Mexican cartel boss who decides to undergo gender-affirming surgery to live as a woman named Emilia Pérez. Directed by the acclaimed French filmmaker Jacques Audiard, the film is a genre-defying spectacle that blends the gritty violence of a crime drama with the vibrant, theatrical elements of a modern musical. Its polarizing reception highlights a crucial discussion about art, ambition, and accessibility in contemporary cinema.
The Star-Powered Ensemble and Visionary Director: Full Cast & Crew Biography
The success and controversy of Emilia Pérez are inextricably linked to the powerhouse talent both in front of and behind the camera. The film's ensemble cast made history by collectively winning the Best Actress award at the 2024 Cannes Film Festival, a rare honor that recognized their combined, stunning performances.
- Karla Sofía Gascón (Emilia Pérez / Juan "Manitas" Del Monte)
- Born: March 31, 1972, in Madrid, Spain.
- Career Highlights: Spanish actress who spent a significant part of her career in the Mexican film and television industry, notably in telenovelas.
- Role in Emilia Pérez: Plays the pivotal dual role of the vicious cartel leader Juan "Manitas" Del Monte and his post-transition self, Emilia Pérez. Her performance is widely hailed as a breakthrough, earning her the historic Cannes Best Actress award alongside her co-stars.
- Zoe Saldaña (Rita Moro Castro)
- Born: June 19, 1978, in Passaic, New Jersey, U.S.
- Career Highlights: Global superstar known for major roles in blockbuster franchises, including *Avatar* (Neytiri), *Guardians of the Galaxy* (Gamora), and *Star Trek* (Uhura).
- Role in Emilia Pérez: Plays Rita Moro Castro, a disillusioned Mexico City lawyer who is enlisted by the cartel boss to facilitate his gender transition. She shared the Cannes Best Actress award.
- Selena Gomez (Jessie Del Monte)
- Born: July 22, 1992, in Grand Prairie, Texas, U.S.
- Career Highlights: Began as a Disney star (*Wizards of Waverly Place*) before transitioning into a successful recording artist and acclaimed dramatic actress (*Only Murders in the Building*).
- Role in Emilia Pérez: Portrays Jessie Del Monte, the wife of the cartel boss. She also shared the Cannes Best Actress award, marking a significant dramatic achievement in her career.
- Jacques Audiard (Director, Writer, Co-Songwriter)
- Born: April 30, 1952, in Paris, France.
- Career Highlights: One of France's most decorated filmmakers, known for gritty, character-driven crime films. Previous major awards include the Palme d'Or for *Dheepan* (2015) and the Grand Prix for *A Prophet* (2009).
- Role in Emilia Pérez: Audiard wrote, directed, and co-wrote the music for the film, basing it on his own opera libretto. His vision is the driving force behind the film’s genre-bending ambition.
Unpacking the Rotten Tomatoes Score: Critics vs. Audience
The core of the Emilia Pérez discussion lies in its wildly divergent Rotten Tomatoes scores. The film has earned a "Certified Fresh" status from critics, with scores hovering around 72% to 76%. This high score reflects the critical establishment's appreciation for its originality, ambitious storytelling, and the powerful, committed performances from the cast, particularly Karla Sofía Gascón. Critics have praised its audacious blend of genres—a "musical thriller" that is "incendiary" and "audacious."
However, the audience reaction is a completely different story. The Audience Score has been reported as low as 16% and generally remains under 31%, indicating that the majority of viewers who rated the film disliked it. This enormous gap—often over 40 percentage points—suggests a fundamental misunderstanding or rejection of the film's unique approach by moviegoers. This phenomenon has led to the film being dubbed "loved by critics, hated by audiences."
The Reasons Behind the Audience Backlash
Several factors contribute to the audience's scathing reviews and low score, making the film one of the most divisive Oscar contenders of the year.
- Genre Mismatch and Tone: The film is a Spanish-language, French-produced, crime-thriller musical. This complex combination of genres can be jarring for a mainstream audience expecting a traditional crime drama or a conventional Hollywood musical. The sudden shifts in tone, from brutal cartel violence to choreographed song-and-dance numbers, proved too much for many viewers.
- Challenging Themes: The central theme—a powerful, violent Mexican cartel boss seeking gender-affirming surgery—is inherently complex and controversial. The film tackles issues of gender identity, redemption, and the nature of evil within the context of a ruthless drug war. For some, the musical format trivialized the serious subject matter, while others found the narrative too heavy or melodramatic.
- Pacing and Length: Some audience reviews have cited the film's ambitious runtime and sometimes erratic pacing as a drawback. The film's maximalist style, driven by Audiard's bold vision, can feel overwhelming or "lost in its own ambitions" to viewers accustomed to more straightforward narratives.
- Oscar Buzz Backlash: As a major frontrunner with a staggering 13 Oscar nominations—the most ever for a non-English film—*Emilia Pérez* has become a target for those who disagree with the Academy's taste. This "Oscars season's villain" status often leads to review bombing or a heightened level of scrutiny from the general public looking to critique what they perceive as "prestige" cinema.
The Legacy of a Polarizing Masterpiece
Despite the audience's lukewarm reception, the critical acclaim and major awards success have cemented Emilia Pérez as a significant cultural event of 2024–2025. Its wins at the Cannes Film Festival, including the prestigious Jury Prize and the historic ensemble Best Actress award, set the stage for its subsequent Oscar dominance.
The film's impact extends beyond mere box office or streaming performance (it had a relatively quiet release on Netflix). It is a powerful example of how cinema can push boundaries by combining seemingly disparate elements—a transgender narrative, a violent crime plot, and a full-blown musical—to create something entirely new. The film's willingness to place women front and center in a traditionally male-led gangster genre is one of its most celebrated thematic elements.
Ultimately, the "Emilia Pérez" Rotten Tomatoes score is less a definitive judgment of quality and more a reflection of its challenging nature. It is a film that demands engagement, rewards critical analysis, and openly rejects the conventions of easy entertainment. The critics saw a visionary, groundbreaking work of art; the audience, for the most part, saw a confusing and over-ambitious experiment. This fascinating critical-audience divide will likely be the film's most enduring legacy, guaranteeing its place in cinematic history as a truly polarizing masterpiece.
Detail Author:
- Name : Gaetano Gulgowski
- Username : swilkinson
- Email : trever81@prosacco.com
- Birthdate : 1985-04-25
- Address : 7504 Schneider Throughway Lake Maceymouth, DE 57029
- Phone : (940) 854-2540
- Company : Dare-Schmeler
- Job : Communications Equipment Operator
- Bio : Laborum qui facere eveniet totam corrupti. Qui enim distinctio doloremque officia architecto. Fuga itaque accusantium illo. Eius ab aut perspiciatis voluptatem.
Socials
twitter:
- url : https://twitter.com/ara_mante
- username : ara_mante
- bio : Qui minima voluptatem aut autem consequuntur. Dolor odit dolorum incidunt. Maxime vero voluptatem id consequatur in. Inventore ipsa qui dolorem.
- followers : 1650
- following : 382
instagram:
- url : https://instagram.com/ara.mante
- username : ara.mante
- bio : Assumenda sed ut ipsum occaecati eos qui. Nam ut ut est fugit fugit.
- followers : 2540
- following : 867
tiktok:
- url : https://tiktok.com/@ara_official
- username : ara_official
- bio : Deserunt suscipit laudantium eum nihil sit ipsa aut.
- followers : 1632
- following : 889
